DOJ Charges 17 People in $1.34 Million Social Security Fraud Crackdown
Federal prosecutors charged 17 people in an enforcement operation targeting alleged Social Security benefits fraud, including a woman accused of hiding her deceased mother’s body in a freezer while continuing to collect benefits.
The Justice Department announced the results Sept. 29, reporting approximately $1.34 million in alleged intended losses. Charges were brought between Aug. 21 and Sept. 18 through coordination among its National Fraud Enforcement Division, U.S. attorney’s offices and the Social Security Administration’s Office of Inspector General. SSA Office of the Inspector General
The reported amount represents intended losses attributed to the alleged schemes, rather than an announced recovery of taxpayer money. The cases involve accusations of collecting payments after recipients died, misusing benefits entrusted to caregivers and providing false information to maintain eligibility.
Among the defendants is Eva Bratcher, charged in the Northern District of Illinois. Prosecutors allege she concealed her mother’s body in a deep freezer in her garage for two years, assumed her identity and collected her Social Security and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program benefits.
Bratcher also allegedly used another Social Security number to obtain additional SNAP benefits. Authorities listed $21,402 in intended losses associated with her case. She faces charges of theft of government property and Social Security fraud, carrying maximum prison terms of 10 years and five years, respectively.
Two other cases involve relatives accused of taking benefits deposited after a family member’s death.
In the Northern District of New York, David Darling allegedly used his deceased brother’s ATM card to withdraw money beginning the day after his brother died. Prosecutors say Social Security continued depositing benefits because it was unaware of the death, allowing Darling to obtain $109,746. His charges include access device fraud, theft of government property and aggravated identity theft.
In the Western District of Pennsylvania, Debra Reed allegedly took retirement benefits paid into her father’s account after his death on Nov. 23, 2020. Prosecutors say she either withdrew the money herself or directed her daughter to obtain and transfer it to her. Authorities attributed $59,070 in losses to the alleged scheme, which continued through October 2023.
The operation also included cases involving representative payees, people entrusted to manage benefits for recipients.
In Michigan, Laura Whisenant allegedly stole or misused $121,980 over seven years while serving as representative payee for her elderly uncle, who had a mental disability. According to prosecutors, he lived in a house without running water, electricity or heat while she diverted his benefits.
Another Michigan defendant, Keshaune Pace, also known as Keshaune Jenkins, allegedly lied about her disabled minor son’s living arrangements to continue receiving his Supplemental Security Income benefits after he left her custody. Prosecutors say she arranged for another person to impersonate her son during a Social Security review.
Authorities attributed $30,000 in misused or improperly obtained benefits to Pace’s case. Of that amount, prosecutors say $6,000 should have supported her son’s needs, while the remaining $24,000 should not have been paid.
Additional defendants were charged in cases across Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Rhode Island, Texas, Ohio, Idaho, Indiana and Michigan. The largest individually listed intended loss was $170,166 in the Northern District of Ohio case against Lizbeth A. Reinhard.
The Justice Department said the operation supports the Trump administration’s broader effort to combat fraud in federal benefit programs. Its National Fraud Enforcement Division was announced April 7.
The charges are allegations. All defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and the listed maximum penalties do not establish what sentences would be imposed following convictions.
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
