Oregon — Cascade Policy Institute President John Charles is urging Oregon lawmakers to reassess support for regional passenger rail following findings from Metro’s Regional Rail Futures Study, commissioned under Senate Bill 5701.
In a letter sent this week to members of the Oregon House and Senate, Charles highlighted conclusions from the Metro-commissioned study that raise significant concerns about the viability of expanding passenger rail service across the Portland metropolitan area.
The study, funded with a $500,000 state appropriation, examined the potential use of existing freight rail corridors for passenger service. According to a supporting report by Cascade adjunct scholar Randal O’Toole, the analysis identified multiple challenges, including high operating costs, the need for extensive infrastructure upgrades, congestion on freight lines, and limited ridership potential along several corridors.
Despite those findings, Metro did not rule out regional rail and instead continued to support long-term rail investments and associated land-use changes near freight corridors.
Charles argues that approach reflects a broader disconnect between regional transit planning and current economic realities. While Portland’s transit system has historically been oriented around a downtown hub, he notes that employment patterns have shifted significantly, with more than 90 percent of jobs now dispersed across the metropolitan area rather than concentrated in the urban core.
“A transit strategy built around fixed rail and a single dominant hub does not match how people live and work today,” the letter states.
The report instead points to bus-based transit as a more adaptable and cost-effective alternative. Buses, Charles argues, can better serve decentralized job centers and evolving travel patterns while avoiding the high capital and operating costs associated with rail infrastructure.
The letter calls on state lawmakers to weigh Metro’s own findings carefully before committing additional public funding to regional passenger rail projects, emphasizing the need for transportation investments that align with current land use and commuting patterns.
About the Author
