November 19, 2026
A student at Adrian High School in eastern Oregon works on a welding project Photo by Larry Moore - Bureau of Land Management

Oregon — The Oregon Department of Education made race a factor in determining how much funding school districts receive through its Secondary Career Pathways vocational education program, issuing rules that award districts additional funding when students of color complete qualifying career training programs, raising questions about whether the funding formula complies with federal anti-discrimination laws.

The Department says the program funds teacher development and technology purchases to support high school programs in fields such as computer programming, health sciences, engineering and industrial technology. Oregon is spending $4.4 million per year on Secondary Career Pathways during the 2025-2027 biennium. The Department in a 2025 report said the program funded more than 749 school programs in the 2023-2025 biennium.

The Legislature created the program in 2015, directing school districts receiving funding to allocate dollars to public schools within the district based on the number of students enrolled in approved career and technical education (CTE) programs, receiving industry certifications and/or who are historically underserved. The Legislature required the State Board of Education, which oversees the Department of Education, to adopt rules defining “historically underserved.”

The Department issued rules the same year that allocated available program funding to school districts based upon a calculation of the number of “points” the district accumulated the prior year. For the purpose of the funding formula, each student can represent up to three points, based on receiving CTE credits, industry credits and being historically underserved. The rules define “historically underserved” to mean “an English language learner, a student of color, an economically disadvantaged student or a student with disabilities.” School districts with more points receive more funding.

Neither the Department’s rules nor the statute define “student of color” means for the purpose of the program. Oregon Roundup Foundation inquired with Department spokesperson Liz Merah via email and a voicemail inquiring how the Department defines “student of color” when allocating Secondary Career Pathways funding, how much funding was allocated based upon students’ race and the amount of program funding by school district. ORF did not receive a response to those questions.

The legal problem

The Department’s decision to tie state education funding in part to students’ race raises serious constitutional and legal questions under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

The Equal Protection Clause, ratified in 1868 in the wake of the Civil War and nearly a century of explicit state discrimination against black people and other unfavored racial groups, prohibits states from denying “any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” The U.S. Supreme Court, most emphatically in its 2023 Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard case, has construed the Equal Protection Clause to invalidate race-conscious university admissions programs, criticizing, among other things, racial categories that were insufficiently defined, overbroad, or disconnected from measurable objectives.

Unlike the admissions programs at issue in Students for Fair Admissions, Oregon’s Secondary Career Pathways program does not confer benefits directly to students; it awards school districts and, according to the statute but not the Department rules, individual schools based upon the race of the students who previously received credits in CTE programs.

Although the U.S. Supreme Court has not directly addressed a school funding formula like Oregon’s, it has repeatedly subjected government programs distributing financial benefits based on race to strict constitutional scrutiny of the type employed in Students for Fair Admissions. That strict scrutiny is nearly always fatal to a challenged state program.

Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act provides, “No person in the United States shall, on the ground of race, color, or national origin, be excluded from participation in, be denied benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any program or activity receiving federal financial assistance.”

Title VI applies to state activities supported by federal funds. Oregon funds Secondary Career Pathways with state dollars, but the Department receives significant federal funds, and all of its programs are subject to Title VI. The allocation of funding to school districts based on the race of students who have previously participated in a district’s CTE programs could deprive students in districts with fewer students meeting the Department’s undefined racial preferences of the benefits of increased state-funded CTE offerings.

Oregon’s reliance on racial criteria that are undefined in staute or administrative rule, and that the Department failed to identify when asked by Oregon Roundup Foundation, further raises questions about whether the state’s funding formula can withstand legal scrutiny.

Written By Jeff Eager

I used AI to help identify and summarize four years of original Oregon Roundup reporting for this article. Oregon Roundup does not use AI-drafted content in its original news reporting.

Find the article and more directly from Oregon Roundup https://oregonroundup.substack.com/p/oregon-uses-race-to-allocate-vocational

Republished by Right Now Oregon with Permission from Oregon Roundup. Oregon Roundup Foundation created this article. ORF is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit corporation dedicated to covering Oregon political and government news.

Leave a Reply