November 16, 2026

Oregon Dept. of Ed Guidance Lists Multiple Gender Identities, Clashing With Biological Science on Sex

0
Oregon Department of Education Gender Expansive Students

Oregon — The Oregon Department of Education’s January 2023 guidance, Supporting Gender Expansive Students: Guidance for Schools, instructs districts to affirm a wide array of gender identities as protected and to be accommodated in names, pronouns, records, facilities, and activities. The document’s terminology appendix defines “gender expansive” as an umbrella for people whose “gender expression and identity expand beyond perceived or expected societal gender norms,” encompassing those who “identify as multiple genders,” “along the binary,” “as no gender,” or “beyond the notion of the man/woman binary entirely.” Specific entries include agender (no specific gender or neutral), genderfluid (identity that “changes and fluctuates”), genderqueer, nonbinary, transgender, Two Spirit, and intersex (framed as variations in sex traits, with note that it is “not often used as a gender identity itself”). “Cisgender” is defined as alignment with sex/gender “assigned at birth or by society, through the enforcement of the gender binary.” “Gender/Sex Assigned at Birth” is described as a classification “often based on physical anatomy at birth and/or karyotyping.”

ODE roots the guidance in Oregon and federal civil-rights protections for gender identity, defined in state law as an individual’s “gender-related identity, appearance, expression or behavior, regardless of whether” it differs from that associated with the sex assigned at birth. The document treats identity as self-determined and instructs schools to affirm it, including nonbinary (X) markers on records and flexible athletic participation for those who do not “consistently identify with the gender binary.”

This framework aligns with social-construction theory of gender: the view that gender is a culturally enforced system of norms and meanings rather than a category grounded in reproductive biology, and that individuals can self-identify across, between, or outside any binary. The language of “system-impacted” identities, societal assignment, and expansion beyond “expected” norms reflects that premise.

Become a Paid Subscriber for Exclusive Content Access and Support Independent News

A November 2025 open-access commentary in the peer-reviewed journal Archives of Sexual Behavior, “Why There Are Exactly Two Sexes” by evolutionary biologist Colin M. Wright, presents the contrasting biological account. Across anisogamous species (those with differently sized gametes), including humans, there are exactly two sexes. Males are organisms whose reproductive system has the biological function of producing small gametes (sperm); females are those whose system has the function of producing large gametes (ova). Because only these two gamete types exist, there are only two sexes.

The definition is functional and organism-level, not a matter of chromosomes, hormones, secondary characteristics, self-identification, or a continuum. Wright notes that this has long been settled in biology; recent challenges in popular and some scholarly writing appear driven by cultural debates over gender identity rather than new evidence about gametes or evolution.

The paper systematically addresses claims that undermine the binary. Treating sex as a “spectrum” on the basis of differences/disorders of sex development (DSDs, sometimes called intersex conditions) fails because developmental variation does not produce a third gamete type; ambiguity does not create intermediate or additional sexes. Karyotype variations (such as XXY) and mating-type systems in non-anisogamous organisms are likewise variations or different concepts within or outside the two sexes, not additional sexes.

Polythetic or multilevel models that aggregate chromosomes, hormones, morphology, behavior, and sometimes “gender identity” into degrees of maleness or femaleness are circular: the traits labeled male- or female-typical derive their meaning from the gamete-based categories they seek to replace. Attempts to decenter gametes ultimately presuppose them. Wright concludes that clear definitions protect scientific coherence across biology and medicine; policy questions of rights and treatment are distinct from redefining the reproductive realities that make the concept of sex useful. Aneuploidies and DSDs describe variation within the two sexes.

ODE’s guidance therefore operationalizes a social-construction framework in which gender identity is decoupled from, and can override, biological sex for institutional purposes. Biological science, as summarized in the Wright commentary, holds that sex remains binary and gamete-defined irrespective of identity claims or the social meanings attached to masculinity and femininity. Intersex conditions, listed in the ODE appendix, are treated in the scientific literature as developmental variations within male or female pathways rather than evidence for multiple sexes or a spectrum of sex itself.

In Oregon public schools, the guidance shapes day-to-day practices, asserted names and pronouns, facility access, athletic eligibility, and record markers, according to self-identification. Critics of such approaches argue that state agencies should ground education policy in empirical biology rather than contested social theory, particularly when the latter is used to redefine sex-based categories in shared spaces and programs funded by taxpayers.

Leave a Reply